WISH YOU ALL VERY HAPPY AND PROSPERUS NEW YEAR 2015

Dear friends,

Because of our Complaint to Central Information Commissioner New Delhi against, CPIO O/o CGMT Haryana for providing incomplete Information  on our second Appeal under RTI Act2005.

CPIO O/o CGMT Haryana has provided some more important information in 53 pages.

Still some specific information is intentionally not supplied, for which One more Complaint will be submit after legal advice of our Advocate to Central Information Commissioner New Delhi, against CPIO O/o CGMT Haryana for providing incomplete Information.

Our Advocate also advice to file complaint in High Court of Punjab & Haryana against,

8 Applicant TTA’s for producing false information before the court.

File No. CIC/BS/A/2013/002535/6217

Complaint under Sec. 18 (1) (e) of RTI Act 2005.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

           

To,                                                                                                   Date 24^th Nov.2014

The Chief Information Commissioner,

Club  Building, Old J.N.U. Campus, New Delhi-110067.                                          

Sir

With reference to the above I submit the following for your consederation.

1) Name , Address of Applicant:       Mr. S.W.PARNERKAR    .

                                                              Shreesakshi Row House No. 4, Behind Bank of                                                                                Maharashtra, Gandharva Nagari, Indira Nagar,

                                                              Nashik- 422009.   Maharashtra.

                                                              Tele.No. Resi.0253-2320202, Mo. 9423969789   

Particulars of Central Public Information Officer( CPIO) Complained against.

2) Name & Address of CPIO.            Mr. Kamal Kumar

                                                              G.M.(HR/Admn) Cum CPIO,

O/o CGMT BSNL  Haryana Circle,                   Ambala133001.

3) Date of submission of Application seeking information;    02/04/2013.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      

4) Date and order No passed on my Second Appeal by C.I.C. New Delhi:

    File No. CIC/BS/A/2013/002535/6217 20 OCTOBER 2014.

                          

5) Statement of facts:

            In compliance with CIC order referred at 4 above CPIO Vide

letter No. Staff/RTI/HR/2013-14/S.W. Parnerkar /14 Dtd 31/10/2014 provided incomplete information hence this complaint.

The details of incomplete information given below.

Point No.	Information sought	Information Provided	Incomplete due to following reasons
1	Copy of affidavit in reply field in the civil Writ petition no. 5608 of 2007. Before Hon’ble. High court for the states of Punjab & Haryana. by the respondent	Only 15 pages of written statement on Writ Petition C.W.P. 5608 on be half of respondent No 1&2 are given.	The Annexures to the written Statement referred there in are not provided hence information provided is incomplete.
2	(a)    In the civil writ petition No. 5608 of 2007. In the   High court for the states of Punjab & Haryana at Punjab in the case Dalbir Sing & others petitioners Vs. BSNL Ltd. & others. After the judgement on 30th May 2008, the advice / opinion / Instructions / Guidelines given by, i)                    BSNL Council ii)                  BSNL Corporate Office legal wings correspondence with CGMT Haryana to be provided.	(a)Received Note sheet 1N to 43N regarding the Writ petition. (b)Correspondence between CGMT & BSNL Corporate Office available in the file at page 4/c,5/c.6/c & 8/c are only provided. (c) Legal opinion of Advocate Shri Madan Mohan provided	Legal opinion given by Sr. counsel Adv. Shri. K.C.Kaushik on 20th Sept.2008 not provided. Letter received from Corporate office referred in Note sheet 25N, said to be kept as 18/c not provided, hence information is not complete. Also it is pertinent to state the legal opinion given by Adv. Shri. Madan Mohan on Date25/07/2008 is not legible.
3	a)      Copy of Note sheet & the correspondence with reference to the communication referred above made with Corporate Office.. Copy of Note sheets for letter & all correspondence culminated the decision for implementing the court order of High Court Punjab & Haryana without filing SLP in Supreme Court.	No separate information is provided except certain remarks from which it can be inferred that Managing Committee on its 104th Meeting on dt.4/11/2008, has taken certain decision in this matter.	Neither the copy of Note sheet nor Letter or correspondence which has culminated in to the decision for implementing the Punjab & Haryana High Court order was provided about the decision taken in the 104th Management Committee Meeting held on 4/11/2008.                         Had this information is not available with CPIO. He should have forwarded my application as per RTI Act to the Corporate Office to provide the required information which was deliberately not followed and there by not provided the information. .This amounts to  refusal  of Information.

            In view of above, I pray your honour to kindly impose suitable penalty on CPIO as per Section 20 (1) of RTI Act 2005for providing incomplete Information in spite of the orders to provide the information by C.I.C. on my Second Appeal.

            Thanking you,

                                                                                    Yours faithfully,

                                                                                S.W. PARNERKAR

                                               

                                                         Tele.No. Resi.0253-2320202, Mo. 9423969789   

                                                         Emai Id:  shirishp1964@gmail.com

                                                                         shirishparnerkar@yahoo.com

Encl.   Copy of the receipt for the Register A.D., for forwarding this complaint to    CPIO  on dt. 24/11/2014,  for their information.

Copy to: 1) CPIO Mr. Kamal Kumar G.M.(HR/Admn), O/o CGMT BSNL Haryana

                                                                                                  Ambala- 133001.

           

                   

          

                                                                                                                                                   

Dear friends,

Complaint is submitted to Central Information Commissioner New Delhi, against, 

CPIO O/o CGMT Haryana for providing incomplete Information. And violation of order of ,

Central Information Commissioner New Delhi  on our second Appeal under RTI Act2005.

Next Date of hearing of  Mumbai CAT Court case  is 6^th Jan. 2015.

Dear friends,

As expected the information supplied by CPIO of CGMT Haryana under RTI 2005,

There is sufficient documentary evidence of intentional mishandling, hiding of facts from the court,  on the part of CGMT Haryana who was dealing with case.

But the information is not complete, and many words are missing in some important documents.

After complete scrutiny of information, and legal advice from our Advocates we may again approach to the Central Information Commission, New Delhi for intervention.

Dear friends,

Congratulations, finally today I have received Information sought from CPIO of CGMT Haryana under RTI 2005.

I have received 68 pages information related with the civil rite petition no. 5608 of 2007.

During the overlook of received information it is almost confirm that we are the victim of corporate terrorism of some of Officers of BSNL Management and Direct Recruit TTA’s.

 After detailed scrutiny of the papers, if we will find that the information is inadequate or tampered, we will again approach to the Central Information Commission, New Delhi for intervention.

Set of received papers is also dispatched to our Advocates for legal advice.

Dear friends,

Today I have received the Decision Notice from Chief Information Commissioner New Delhi stating that,

“As agreed by the CPIO the information requested by the appellant in his RTI application dated 02/04/2013 should be supplied to him, free of cost, within 15 days from the date of receipt of this notice order.”

BASANT SETH

Information Commissioner

Dear friends,

As per our Advocate advise process to register the Forum of Officiating JTO’s of BSNL, is initiated. Process of Registration will be completed in coming month’s period.

Be prepared for further legal battle.

Dear friends,

Wish you very happy Deepawali 2014.

S.W.PARNERKAR.

Dear friends,

Congratulations,  Hearing on our Second appeal under RTI 2005 is succeeded today, finally CPIO Of CGMT Haryana agreed to supply the Information sought unconditionally within 15 days without any cost.

We hope that full true, actual and complete information will be supplied.

If we find that the information is inadequate or tampered, we will again approach to the Central Information Commission, New Delhi for intervention.

We tried to avoid to insist for imposing penalty over CPIO, CGMT Haryana for intentional delay without any valid reason in giving the Information considering the fact that Officer In charge of CPIO & First Appellate Authority are not responsible for mishandlings in the  civil rite petition no. 5608 of 2007.

Let’s hope this could be the first step in finding the truth how SNATTA managed civil rite petition no. 5608 of 2007. In the   High court for the states of Punjab & Haryana in the case Dalbir Sing & others petitioners Vs. BSNL Ltd. & others. in their favour?

Dear friends,

Our Mumbai CAT Court Case was heard on 16^th Oct.2014.

Case is again posted to 20^th Nov. 2014 for final hearing.

Our Advocate advised to register the Forum of Officiating JTO’s of BSNL, with the purpose to protect the legitimate rights of the group of officiating JTO’s of BSNL.

Dear friends,

Congratulations, that Notice of Hearing is served by the

Central Information Commission, New Delhi on our Second Appeal field by us before Chief Information Commissioner  on 25 Sept. 2013.

 The appeal was filed for factual information regarding   civil rite petition no. 5608 of 2007. In the   High court for the states of Punjab & Haryana at Punjab in the case Dalbir Sing & others petitioners Vs. BSNL Ltd. & others.

The hearing is fixed on 20^th October 2014 through Video Conference at NIC Computer Centre, Collect orate Office Nashik for applicant  and,

Nic Studio, Mini Secretariat Ambala City, for CPIO of BSNL CGMT Haryana. Before Honourable Shri Basant Seth, Information Commissioner New Delhi.

The Appeal field is as follow,

The  Right of Information Act 2005.

Second   appeal before Chief Information Commissioner,

Club  Building, Old J.N.U. Campus, New Delhi-110067.                                          

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Sir,                                                                                      Date 25^th July 2013.

 Being aggrieved by the decision of first Appellate Authority, I hereby file this second appeal for your kind consideration and orders.

           

The particulars of my application are as under.

1) Name , Address of Applicant:       Mr. S.W.PARNERKAR    .

                                                              Shreesakshi Row House No. 4, Behind Bank of                                                                                Maharashtra, Gandharva Nagari, Indira Nagar,

                                                              Nashik- 422009.   Maharashtra.

                                                              Tele.No. Resi.0253-2320202, Mo. 9423969789   

2) Name & Address of CPIO.            Mr. Arun Kumar

  Sr. G.M.(HR/Admn) Cum CPIO,

O/o CGMT BSNL  Haryana Circle,                   Ambala133001.

3) Name & Address of First                Mr. G.K.Upadhyay

 Appellate  Authority                            Chief General Manager BSNL Haryana

                                                                Circle, Ambala- 133001.

4) Date of RTI   Application  &             RTI application  Dt.  02/04/2013.Enclosed

                                                                                                               As Annexure I                                                                                                                                                                                       

    Date of First Appeal                            Dt . 13/05/2013. Enclosed as Annexure III

5) Particulars   of   decision of CPIO     Letter no. Staff/RTI/HR/13-14/S.W.Parnerkar   

                                                           /4.  dtd.  27/04/13. Enclosed as          Annexure II

    & First Appellate Authority               Letter no. Staff/RTI/HR/13-14/04- 4/Appeal/

                                                             S.W/6.  Dtd  25/06/13  Enclosed as AnnexureIV

6) Date of receipt of reply by

     Applicant from CPIO    &                    Dt. 01/05/2013.  

    First Appellate Authority                      Dt. 01/07/2013.

7) Details of information sought.

 

   Information required

a)      Copy of affidavits in reply field in the civil rite petition no. 5608 of 2007. Before Hon’ble. High court for the states of Punjab & Haryana. by the respondent.

b)      In  the civil rite petition no. 5608 of 2007. In the   High court for the states of Punjab & Haryana at Punjab in the case Dalbir Sing & others petitioners Vs. BSNL Ltd. & others. After the judgement on 30^th May 2008, the advice / opinion / Instructions / Guidelines given by,

i)                    BSNL Council

ii)                  BSNL Corporate Office legal wings correspondence with CGMT Haryana to be provided.

c)      Copy of Note sheet & the correspondence with reference to the communication referred above made with Corporate Office..

Copy of Note sheets for letter & all correspondence culminated the decision for implementing the court order of High Court Punjab & Haryana without filing SLP in Supreme Court.

8) Brief facts of the case

            A Civil Writ petition was filed by 8 Telecom Technical Assistants (TTA’s) of BSNL Haryana Circle at Punjab & Haryana High Court.

The outcome of the case has affected the promotion of about 2500 senior TTA’s all over India including the applicant, due to the suspected mishandling of the case by the CGMT Haryana BSNL hence the information were sought.

9) Reason Grounds for this appeal

     The information sought was refused by the CPIO & First Appellate Authority under section 8(1) (h) of the RTI Act.2005 and also stated that the disclosure will not be in the interest of BSNL/ Dept. as case is pending and it is subjudice.

            Reason given for refusal of information is not tenable as there is no investigation or apprehension of prosecution of offender is involved in this court case, hence Section 8(1)(h) of RTI Act 2005 cannot be invoked. Also merely by providing this information, there is no act of subjudice committed by CPIO & First Appellative Authority.

Prayer / Relief sought

            The Honourable Chief Information Commissioner be pleased to direct the CPIO to provide the information sought.

Declaration

            I hereby by state, the information and particulars given above are true to the best of my knowledge and belief. I also declare that this matter is not previously field with this commission, nor is pending with any court or tribunal or authority.

            Thanking you,

                                                                                    Yours faithfully,

                                                                                    S.W. PARNERKAR

Encl. Annexure I TO IV as detailed above

 Annexure V,Is the  Copy of the receipt for the Register A.D., for forwarding this application to CPIO & First Appellate Authority on dt. 25/07/2013,  for their information.

Copy to: 1) CPIO Mr. Arun Kumar Sr. G.M.(HR/Admn), O/o CGMT BSNL Haryana

               2) FAAuthority. Mr. G.K.Upadhyay Chief General Manager BSNL Haryana       

                                                                                     Circle, Ambala- 133001.

To,

          The Chief Information Commissioner,

          New Delhi- 110067

Sub:- Request for early disposal of my second appeal, submitted on

           dt 25/09/2013

                  

                               Ref.: Dairy No. 155641 Dtd. 21/08/2013.

                   Respected Sir,

With reference to above dairy No.155641 Dtd.  21/08/2013.  I request with this letter to your honour kindly dispose off my appeal at early date, directing to CPIO & First appellate Authority to provide the information sought and obliged.

Sir, I am waiting for your honours reply on appeal since 25^th Sept. 2013.

Sir, I have also send First Request letter for early disposal of my appeal on 09/01/2014.

       And two requests on line through Web site of Information commissioner on

       Dt. 10/04/2014 & 14/04/2014.

Second Request letter for early disposal of my appeal on 25/04/2014.

Sir with this request letter I humbly request you that the further delay in getting information may result in denial of justice, and right to get the information under the RTI Act 2005. I also submitting the factual information, and reason related to the information sought under RTI 2005.

Sir CPIO & First Appellate Authority is intentionally denying the information. The delay is causing undue hardship to the 1800 DOT recruited employees of BSNL all over India including my self.

          Thanking you,

          In anticipation of early favourable action pl.           

                                                                                                                                                                                                            Yoursfaithfully         

                                                                                      S.W.PARNERKAR

Enclose: 1)  Copy of All appeal documents submitted on 25/09/2013.

               2)  Letter of Post Office about delivery of appeal letters to  ,   ,                   CIC office

               3) Letter of factual information of injustice with us.

Copy to  

1) Shri Narendra Modiji, Honbl. Prime Minister Of India for  his kind intervention to protect the interest of sufferers of corporatization of DOT.

 2)Chief General Manager Punjab & Haryana, Ambala

 (First Appellate Authority).